Is the 'Ex' Knife Block a Great Gag Gift or Just Junk?

Author Byline: By David Miller / Last updated on September 1, 2025

Hey everyone, David Miller here.

My good friend Sarah just went through one of those breakups. The kind that involves packing boxes, changing Netflix passwords, and rediscovering what it feels like to have the entire bed to yourself. As she settled into her new downtown apartment, I wanted to get her a housewarming gift that wasn't another scented candle or a generic potted plant. It needed to be functional, a little bit sassy, and something that would make her laugh every time she saw it.

That’s when I stumbled upon it online: the "Ex-Boyfriend" Knife Holder. A gleaming, stainless-steel figure in a rather unfortunate, knife-receptive pose. My first thought was, "This is either the most brilliant, cathartic kitchen gadget ever made or a flimsy piece of junk that’s all gimmick and no substance." There was only one way to find out. I ordered the 2025 model to see if it could stand up to real-world use in a real-world kitchen.

Is the 'Ex' Knife Block a Great Gag Gift or Just Junk?

My friend needed a laugh (and a new knife block). I tested the infamous 2025 'Ex' holder. My brutally honest review on if it's worth your money.

The Bottom Line Up Front (BLUF)

Honestly, I was shocked. This is a surprisingly well-made and functional knife block that also happens to be a hilarious conversation starter. It’s built far better than a "joke" gift has any right to be.

Our Rating Breakdown

• Build Quality & Durability: 8.5/10 (The stainless steel is hefty and the base is rock-solid. This isn't cheap plastic.)
• Design & "Gag" Factor: 9.5/10 (It perfectly executes its humorous premise. It gets a laugh from almost everyone.)
• Functionality & Safety: 7.5/10 (Holds standard knives securely with protective sheaths, but capacity is limited for serious chefs.)
• Value for Money: 8.0/10 (You’re paying a premium for the novelty, but the quality build helps justify the price tag.)

Overall Score: 8.4/10✨✨✨✨✨✨

Key Specifications at a Glance

• Material: Brushed Stainless Steel
• Dimensions: 15.5" H x 10" W
• Weight: ~4 lbs (1.8 kg)
• Knife Slots: 5 (for Paring, Utility, Carver, Bread, and Chef's Knife)
• Base: Non-slip, weighted base for stability
• Included: Knife holder only (knives not included)

Unboxing and First Impressions

The holder arrived in a surprisingly discreet brown box—no giant "HERE'S YOUR VOODOO DOLL KNIFE BLOCK" text on the side, thankfully. Inside, the unit was securely packed in foam. Assembly was a non-issue; it was already fully built.

My immediate first impression was the weight. I was expecting something light and tinny, but this thing has some real heft. The brushed stainless steel finish felt premium, not like a cheap novelty item you’d find in a dollar store. It felt… substantial. Running my hand over the figure, the edges were smooth and the construction felt solid. The weighted base was a great touch, a clear sign that the designers were thinking about safety and not just laughs.

Putting It to the Test: Real-World Performance

I brought the block over to Sarah's new place, and her reaction—a moment of stunned silence followed by a burst of genuine laughter—was worth the price of admission alone. But the real test began when we started loading it with her actual knives.

First, the Stability Test. I placed her 8-inch chef's knife in the top slot and gave the counter a good shake. The block didn't budge. Pulling the knife out quickly didn't cause any tipping or sliding, thanks to that heavy base. That was a huge relief; a wobbly knife block is a dangerous one.

Next, Knife Fit and Protection. We tested a mix of her Wüsthof and Victorinox knives. They slid in smoothly. A closer look inside the slots revealed plastic sheaths, which is crucial. This means the stainless-steel body won't dull your blades every time you insert or remove them. It's a small but critical detail that separates a good product from a cheap gimmick.

The final, and perhaps most important test, was the Conversation Starter Test. A few days later, she had a couple of friends over. They all immediately noticed it, and it became the centerpiece of conversation. It broke the ice and filled her new kitchen with laughter. Mission accomplished.

What Real Users Love (The Pros)

• It's a Genuinely Hilarious Conversation Piece: This is its main selling point, and it delivers. Why this matters to you: It adds personality and a dose of humor to a space that's often purely utilitarian. It's an icebreaker, a mood-lifter, and a statement piece.
• Surprisingly Solid and Well-Built: The stainless steel construction feels premium and is built to last, unlike cheap plastic alternatives. Why this matters to you: It means your "joke" gift doesn't feel cheap. It has the look and feel of a quality kitchen appliance. When I gave it to Sarah, she was impressed by the weight before she even figured out what it was.
• Stable and Safe Design: The weighted, non-slip base is a critical safety feature that works exceptionally well. Why this matters to you: You can confidently grab a knife without worrying about the whole thing toppling over and creating a dangerous situation.

Common Complaints & Potential Deal-Breakers (The Cons)

• The Humor Isn't for Everyone: Let's be honest, this is a very specific type of humor. It might not land well in a more traditional or formal kitchen setting. Why this matters to you: You really need to know your audience if you're giving this as a gift. It's perfect for a friend like Sarah, but maybe not for your grandmother.
• Limited Knife Capacity: With only five slots, it’s not designed for serious home chefs with extensive knife collections. Why this matters to you: If you have a 12-piece knife set or specialty blades like a Santoku or cleaver, you’ll need an additional storage solution.
• Can Be Awkward to Clean: The nooks and crannies of the human figure shape can collect dust or kitchen grime more easily than a simple wooden block. Why this matters to you: It requires a bit more care with a detail brush or cloth to keep it looking pristine compared to a simple block.

Is It Built to Last? Durability and Long-Term Value

This is where the 2025 model really surprised me. I've seen older, cheaper plastic versions of this concept that yellow over time and feel flimsy. This stainless steel construction is a game-changer. It's resistant to rust, staining, and chipping. The solid welds mean there are no creaky joints. This isn't a disposable gag gift you'll toss in a year. It’s a durable piece of kitchen hardware that just happens to be shaped like a person. The long-term value here comes from investing in a version made of real, quality materials.

Best Alternatives (The Competition)

If the "Ex" is a bit too much for you, but you still want something unique, here are a couple of great options:

1. For the Elegant Minimalist: The HÖLM Magnetic Walnut Block. A beautiful, open-air design that uses powerful magnets to hold your knives. It's pure class and showcases your blades like art.
2. For a Different Brand of Humor: The Spartan Knife Block. This block looks like a Spartan warrior holding a shield, with the knives forming his armaments. It's still fun and nerdy, but perhaps a little less... aggressive.

Comparison Table

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)

1. Does the knife block come with knives?
   No, this model is the block only. This allows you to use your own existing set of quality knives.
2. Is it stable enough to be safe on the counter?
   Absolutely. The weighted base is its best safety feature. It's very difficult to knock over during normal use.
3. What are the maximum knife sizes it can hold?
   It's designed for a standard set, including an 8" chef's knife, an 8" bread knife, an 8" carver, a 5" utility knife, and a 3.5" paring knife.
4. How do you clean the stainless steel?
   A soft cloth with a bit of warm, soapy water works best. For fingerprints or smudges, a stainless steel cleaner will make it shine like new.
5. Will it scratch or dull my knives?
   No. The internal plastic sheaths are designed specifically to protect the blade's edge from making contact with the metal body.
6. Is the finish prone to showing fingerprints?
   Like most brushed stainless steel, it can show fingerprints if your hands are oily. However, they wipe off very easily.

Final Thoughts & Recommendation

When I saw Sarah laughing in her new kitchen, arranging her knives in this ridiculous, therapeutic holder, I knew I'd made the right choice. It wasn't just a knife block; it was a symbol of her starting fresh with a sense of humor.

So, who is this for? It’s for anyone with a wicked sense of humor. It’s the perfect housewarming gift for a friend reclaiming their space. It’s for the person who believes a kitchen should have as much personality as the food that comes out of it.

Who should skip it? If you're a minimalist, a professional chef who needs a 15-slot block, or if the humor just doesn’t land with you, then this isn't your product. But if you smiled while reading this review, you already know the answer. It’s a well-built, functional, and hilarious piece that does its job and makes you laugh.

For that, it gets a strong recommendation from me.

Call to Action

If you think this is the perfect blend of function and fun for your kitchen or a friend's, you won't be disappointed by the quality. Go for it.

Audience Growth & Engagement

Become a WowShopList Insider

Love discovering products that are genuinely worth it? I know I do. Subscribe to my exclusive WowShopList Weekly newsletter. Each week, I send one personal email featuring the most unique, innovative, and valuable product I've found—my 'hidden gem' of the week. It's 100% free to join now, and you'll be locked in for life. We plan to make this a paid newsletter in the future, but our founding members will always get it for free.

We hope this in-depth review helps you make a confident choice! To continue your research, check out some of our other popular guides:

• The Always Pan 2.0: One Year Later, Is It Still My Go-To?
• I Tested 5 'Smart' Coffee Mugs—Only One Was Worth the Money
• Why This $30 Japanese Chef's Knife Replaced My $150 Wüsthof
• The Ultimate Housewarming Gift Guide (That Isn't a Boring Candle)
• Are Robot Vacuums That Mop Actually Good? A Brutally Honest Look at the Roborock Q7
• 5 Kitchen Gadgets Under $50 That I Genuinely Use Every Single Day

Now I'd love to hear from you! Drop a comment below with your experience or any questions I didn't cover. I read every single one.