Is This Crossword Toilet Paper a Genius Gag Gift?

Author Byline: By David Miller / Last updated on August 16, 2025

Introduction

Alright, let's talk about party-hosting pressure. My wife, Sarah, and I throw this big holiday party every year, and I've somehow become the guy responsible for the "quirky details." You know, the little things people discover and talk about all night. One year it was a motion-activated goat that screamed in the coat closet. A huge hit. This year, the pressure was on. While scrolling for White Elephant gift ideas, I stumbled upon it: Crossword Puzzle Toilet Paper. My first thought was, "Brilliant." My second thought was, "Is it just a cheap, unusable roll of paper with blurry print that will make me look lazy?" There’s a fine line between a clever gag and a total dud. So, I ordered a roll to find out if it was worthy of our guest bathroom.

Is This Crossword Toilet Paper a Genius Gag Gift?

Testing the Island Dogs Crossword Puzzle Toilet Paper. Is this 3-ply funny TP a hilarious party hit or just a flimsy gag? My honest review.

GO TO AMAZON

The Bottom Line Up Front (BLUF)

This is one of the best-executed gag gifts I've seen in years. It's a genuinely funny and clever concept that gets people talking, and the toilet paper itself is surprisingly usable.

Our Rating Breakdown

• Gag Factor / Humor: 9/10 (It's a clever, multi-layered joke that works on discovery, not just a cheap laugh.)
• Print Quality & Clarity: 8/10 (The crossword is impressively clear and legible, which is essential for the gag to land.)
• Actual Usability (as TP): 6/10 (It's 3-ply and far from sandpaper. It won't replace your Charmin, but it's a step above gas-station quality.)
• Value for Money: 7/10 (You're paying a premium for the novelty, but the quality of the joke and the laughs it generates make it worth it for a special occasion.)

Overall Score: 7.5/10✨✨✨✨✨✨

Key Specifications at a Glance

• Product: Island Dogs Crossword Puzzle Novelty Toilet Paper
• Ply Count: 3-Ply
• Sheets Per Roll: 200
• Material: Paper (Ink is soy-based and safe)
• Special Feature: A repeating crossword puzzle printed on every sheet.

Unboxing and First Impressions

The roll arrives in simple, clear plastic shrink-wrap, which is exactly what you want—it lets the product speak for itself. My first surprise was the feel. I expected a flimsy, almost transparent roll like the kind you find in public restrooms. But this roll felt... substantial. It has a decent heft to it. Unrolling the first few sheets, I was immediately impressed by the print quality. The lines were crisp, the numbers were clear, and the clues were perfectly legible. This wasn't a blurry, cheap knock-off. It looked like someone actually cared about the execution of the joke.

Putting It to the Test: Real-World Performance

You can't really "test" toilet paper in a lab, so I opted for a field test. I swapped out the normal roll in our guest bathroom a few days before my brother-in-law, Mark, was coming over. Mark is my litmus test for this stuff; he notices everything.

Sure enough, about an hour into his visit, he walks out of the bathroom with a huge grin on his face. "Okay," he said, holding up his phone with a picture of the roll, "You win. Where did you get this?" That's the test right there. It passed. The goal of this product isn't absorbency or softness—it's to elicit that exact reaction.

For due diligence, I did try to solve one of the puzzles (with a pen, not in its final use, mind you). The paper takes ink without smudging much, and the puzzles are real, albeit simple. It’s the perfect level of difficulty for its… intended venue. It's a hilarious and surprisingly functional piece of bathroom literature.

What Real Users Love (The Pros)

• A Genuinely Clever Concept: The joke isn't just "ha, stuff printed on toilet paper." The crossword puzzle invites interaction and discovery. Why this matters to you: It’s a guaranteed conversation starter at a party, far more engaging than a simple picture or a crude phrase. I saw this firsthand with Mark's reaction.
• Surprisingly Good Quality Paper: It's 3-ply and doesn't feel like you're using sandpaper. Why this matters to you: A cheap-feeling gag gift can feel lazy. This shows you cared enough to get the 'good' funny toilet paper, which makes the joke even better.
• The Print is Clear and Legible: The entire premise hinges on this, and Island Dogs nailed it. The ink is dark, the font is clear, and the puzzle is actually solvable. Why this matters to you: The gag actually works. Guests can read it, laugh at the clues, and appreciate the detail you put into your bathroom decor.

Common Complaints & Potential Deal-Breakers (The Cons)

• It's Expensive for a Single Roll: Let's be honest, you're not buying this for its value-per-sheet. Why this matters to you: You have to view this as a party supply or a gift, not a household staple. For a one-time laugh, the price is fair, but it's not for daily use.
• The Puzzles are Repetitive: The same small puzzle is printed over and over again on the roll. Why this matters to you: This isn't for the serious puzzle enthusiast. It's designed for that first moment of discovery, not for a month of challenging new brain teasers.
• Slight Ink Smell Initially: When you first open the plastic, there's a faint smell of the soy-based ink. Why this matters to you: It's minor and fades almost immediately once it's out in the air, but if you're extremely sensitive to smells, it's worth noting.

Is It Built to Last? Durability and Long-Term Value

For a consumable product, "durability" means something different. This isn't about whether the roll will last you a month—it won't and it shouldn't. The "long-term value" here is in the memory of the joke.

This product is "built to last" in the sense that the impression it makes is durable. The fact that it's 3-ply and well-printed means the joke lands with quality. A flimsy, 1-ply roll would feel cheap and be forgotten. This one feels like a premium gag gift. The durable memory it creates is what you're paying for, and in that regard, its value is excellent.

Best Alternatives (The Competition)

If you're in the market for novelty TP, the crossword puzzle isn't your only option. Here are a couple of others I've seen:

1. Sudoku Puzzle Toilet Paper: A direct competitor for the puzzle-lover. It offers the same interactive gag but for a more numbers-oriented person.
2. Funny Money "Hundred Dollar Bill" Toilet Paper: A different kind of humor. It’s less about being clever and more about the blatant joke of using "money" as toilet paper.

Comparison Table

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)

• Is the ink on the toilet paper safe?
  Yes, according to the manufacturer, the ink is soy-based and non-toxic, making it perfectly safe for its intended use.
• Can you actually write on it with a pen to solve the puzzle?
  Surprisingly, yes! I tried it with a ballpoint pen, and the paper is thick enough that it doesn't immediately tear or smudge. It's a fun gimmick.
• How does it feel compared to regular toilet paper like Charmin or Scott?
  It's definitely not as soft as a premium brand like Charmin. It's a solid 3-ply that's functional and not scratchy, but you're buying it for the laughs, not for luxury.
• Is this a good White Elephant gift?
  It's an excellent White Elephant gift, especially for a group with a good sense of humor. It's unique, funny, and under the typical $20-$25 price limit.
• Are the puzzles hard?
  Not at all. The clues are very simple and general knowledge-based, which is perfect for a casual setting. Think "TV Guide" crossword, not "New York Times."
• Does the ink bleed or rub off?
  In my testing, no. The ink is well-set and didn't come off on my hands or smudge during normal handling.

Final Thoughts & Recommendation

So, did the Crossword Puzzle Toilet Paper earn its spot in my party-planning hall of fame? Absolutely. It passed the brother-in-law test with flying colors and became a genuine, laugh-out-loud talking point at our party.

This isn't just toilet paper; it's a piece of interactive art for your bathroom. If you're a host looking for that one clever detail that people will remember, or if you need a can't-miss gag gift or White Elephant contribution, buy this roll. It's a small price to pay for a joke that so perfectly lands with quality and wit.

Call to Action

I hope this detailed look helps you decide if this is the right kind of fun for your home or next gift exchange. It's the little details that make life more enjoyable!

Audience Growth & Engagement

"Become a WowShopList Insider"

"Love discovering products that are genuinely worth it? I know I do. Subscribe to my exclusive WowShopList Weekly newsletter. Each week, I send one personal email featuring the most unique, innovative, and valuable product I've found—my 'hidden gem' of the week. It's 100% free to join now, and you'll be locked in for life. We plan to make this a paid newsletter in the future, but our founding members will always get it for free."

"We hope this in-depth review helps you make a confident choice! To continue your research, check out some of our other popular guides:"

• The 5 Best White Elephant Gifts Under $25 That People Will Actually Fight For
• Hosting a Killer Party? Here Are 7 Small Details That Make All the Difference
• Uncommon Goods Review: Are Their Quirky Gifts Actually Good Quality?
• I Tested 3 'Smart' Mugs: Is the Ember Mug Really Worth $150?
• The Best Board Games for Adults That Aren't Boring
• Beyond the Stanley Cup: The Best Insulated Tumblers You've Never Heard Of

"Now I'd love to hear from you! Drop a comment below with your experience or any questions I didn't cover. I read every single one."