Gunslinger TP Holder Review: Man Cave Perfect? (2025)

Author Byline: By David Miller / Last updated on July 22, 2025

Introduction

For years, my bathroom decor was dictated by two things: my landlord's "magnolia or nothing" policy and whatever was cheapest at Target. It was functional, sure, but it had all the personality of a cardboard box.

So when my wife and I finally bought our first house, I had one, very specific, non-negotiable dream: a basement bathroom that was 100% my "man cave" sanctuary. I'm talking a little bit rustic, a little bit rugged, and a whole lot of not boring.

I got the dark paint, the slate-style floor tiles, the Edison bulb fixture... but something was missing. The final touch. The chrome toilet paper holder the builder installed was screaming "suburban McMansion," not "saloon." My hunt began for something unique, something that would make a guest chuckle and say, "Okay, that's cool." And that’s when I stumbled upon the Wild West Gunslinger Double Pistol Holster Toilet Paper Holder.

It looked almost too perfect. But was it a genuinely rugged piece of decor or just a cheap, plasticky gimmick? I ordered one to find out. If you're on a similar quest to banish bathroom boredom, this review is your definitive guide.

Gunslinger TP Holder Review: Man Cave Perfect?

Is this Wild West Gunslinger toilet paper holder the perfect touch for your themed bathroom? My hands-on review reveals if it's rugged or just rough.

GO TO AMAZON

The Bottom Line Up Front (BLUF)

• Who is this for? Anyone designing a themed bathroom (Western, rustic, man cave), bar, or just loves a good conversation starter that’s surprisingly functional.
• Who should skip it? Minimalists, anyone with a sleek modern aesthetic, or those who value a quick, one-handed roll change above all else.

My Final Score: 8.2/10✨✨✨✨✨✨

What Real Users Love (The Pros)

• Unbeatable "Wow" Factor: This isn't just a toilet paper holder; it's a statement piece. It’s the first thing people notice and comment on.
  • Why this matters to you: It instantly injects personality into a space that’s often overlooked, making your bathroom memorable for all the right reasons.
  • In my own testing, the first time my buddy came over, he walked out of the bathroom laughing and said, "Dude, where did you GET that?" That's the exact reaction I was hoping for.
• Surprisingly Solid Build: Made of a heavy-duty resin, it has a satisfying heft. It doesn't feel cheap or flimsy in the slightest.
  • Why this matters to you: You can be confident it won't crack or feel like a cheap toy. It's built to last and looks more expensive than it is.
• The Double-Roll Advantage: The twin "holsters" mean you can stock two rolls at once.
  • Why this matters to you: It’s genuinely practical. You're half as likely to have that dreaded "uh-oh" moment when a roll runs out.
  • Honestly, this has been an unexpected bonus. My wife even commented that she wishes our upstairs bathroom holder held two rolls.

Common Complaints & Potential Deal-Breakers (The Cons)

• Installation Takes Patience: This isn't your simple spring-loaded holder. You need to be precise with your measurements and use a level to get it right.
  • Why this matters to you: If you're not comfortable with a drill and wall anchors, you might find the installation a little frustrating. It’s a 15-minute job, not a 2-minute one.
• Changing Rolls is a Two-Handed Job: The design uses two separate rods that slide through the rolls and rest in the holsters. It's secure, but not as quick as a simple pop-out holder.
  • Why this matters to you: If ultimate convenience is your top priority, the slight extra effort here might become a minor annoyance over time.
  • Honestly, the bulky design was a bit of a process to get used to. It's a small price to pay for the style, but something to keep in mind if you have kids who will be changing the rolls.
• It's Resin, Not Real Leather/Wood: While it looks great from a few feet away, up close you can tell it's a molded and painted resin piece.
  • Why this matters to you: Just set your expectations correctly. You're paying for the "look and feel," not for genuine artisanal materials.

Feature Deep Dive: The "Rugged Charm" vs. Daily Function

The biggest question I had was whether the awesome design would get in the way of its basic job. The answer is a classic "it depends."

The "double holster" design is the hero here. It's not just for show. Holding two full-sized rolls is a legitimate upgrade for any bathroom, especially a guest bath. The rods are simple, they slide out easily, and they hold the rolls securely. There's no squeaking or wobbling.

However, the trade-off is the process. You can't just slap a new roll on. You have to pull the rod out, put it through the new roll, and seat it back in the holster. It takes maybe 10 seconds. Is it a deal-breaker? For me, absolutely not. The visual payoff is more than worth it. But if you live in a house where no one ever seems to be able to change the roll on a simple holder, this one won't magically solve that problem. It’s a conscious choice: you're choosing style and personality over lightning-fast utility.

Best Alternatives (The Competition)

1. For a More Industrial Vibe: Industrial Pipe Toilet Paper Holder. If the "cowboy" theme is too specific, but you still want a rugged, masculine look, these pipe-style holders are a fantastic alternative. They are easier to install and offer a similar DIY, workshop-chic feel without the novelty.
2. For a Different Kind of Novelty: T-Rex Skull Toilet Paper Holder. If what you really want is a conversation piece, but Western isn't your thing, the world of novelty TP holders is vast. A T-Rex skull, for example, achieves the same goal of "memorable bathroom decor" for a completely different kind of nerd (like me).

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)

• Q1: How hard is it to install?
  It comes with screws and wall anchors. You'll need a drill, a Phillips head screwdriver, and a small level. If you're comfortable hanging a picture frame, you can handle this. Just measure twice!
• Q2: Does it hold jumbo or mega-sized toilet paper rolls?
  Yes, it fits standard and most "double" rolls without a problem. The super-stuffed "mega" or "jumbo" rolls might be a tight squeeze at first, but once you use them a bit, they fit fine.
• Q3: Is it made of real leather or wood?
  No, it's made from a durable, heavy painted resin. The detail is impressive, but it is not made from authentic holster materials.
• Q4: Can you use it with just one roll of toilet paper?
  Absolutely. It looks perfectly fine with just one roll loaded in one of the holsters if you prefer.

Final Thoughts & Recommendation

So, did the Gunslinger Holster give my man cave bathroom the final, perfect touch I was looking for? Absolutely. It tied the whole room together and delivered on its promise of rugged charm. Every time I see it, I smile. It solved my "boring bathroom" problem perfectly.

It’s not for everyone, and it's certainly not for the minimalist. It's a piece of functional art that prioritizes personality. If you're the kind of person who names your car or has strong opinions about the best brand of BBQ sauce, this is probably for you. It's a small detail that says a lot.

If you’re looking for a unique, well-built, and fun piece to complete your themed space, I can wholeheartedly recommend it.

Call to Action

If you feel this is the right choice to solve your 'boring bathroom' problem, you can check the latest price and purchase it through the link below. It helps support our in-depth reviews at no extra cost to you. We really appreciate it!

Audience Growth & Engagement

Become a WowShopList Insider

Love discovering products that are genuinely worth it? I know I do. Subscribe to my exclusive WowShopList Weekly newsletter. Each week, I send one personal email featuring the most unique, innovative, and valuable product I've found—my 'hidden gem' of the week. It's 100% free to join now, and you'll be locked in for life. We plan to make this a paid newsletter in the future, but our founding members will always get it for free.

We hope this in-depth review helps you make a confident choice! To continue your research, check out some of our other popular guides:

• I Tested 5 'Quiet' Mini-Fridges, and Only One Didn't Hum During My Zoom Calls
• The Best Garage Lighting of 2024: I Finally Made My Workshop Usable After Dark
• Are Smart Meat Thermometers Worth It? A Skeptic's Guide to the Perfect Brisket

Now I'd love to hear from you! Drop a comment below with your experience or any questions I didn't cover. I read every single one.