Maneater PS4 Review: Still Worth a Bite in 2025?

Author Byline: By David Miller / Last updated on July 22, 2025

Introduction

Ever wondered what it’s like to be the apex predator? To trade complex moral choices for the simple, satisfying crunch of a hunter's boat? That's the wonderfully chaotic premise of Maneater, the self-proclaimed "ShaRkPG" (Shark Role-Playing Game). It's a title that promises bloody, open-world mayhem from a perspective we rarely get to see in gaming.

But years after its initial splash, a crucial question remains: Is Maneater a genuinely great game, or just a one-trick ponyfish? After analyzing hundreds of user reviews and sinking dozens of hours into the murky waters of Port Clovis, I've got the definitive answer. This isn't just another summary; this is the final guide you'll need to decide if this aquatic adventure is worth your time and money.

Maneater PS4 Review: Still Worth a Bite in 2025?

Is Maneater on PS4 still fun? Our deep-dive review covers the pros, repetitive cons, and if this unique "ShaRkPG" is worth your money today.

Go to Amazon

The Bottom Line Up Front (BLUF)

• Who It's For: Gamers looking for a unique, hilarious, and satisfyingly chaotic open-world romp. If you love B-movie charm and a simple, addictive gameplay loop, you'll have a blast.
• Who Should Skip: Players who crave deep, complex narratives or get easily bored by repetitive mission structures. If you're looking for the next 100-hour epic, this isn't it.

Final Score: 7.5/10✨✨✨✨✨✨

What Real Users Love (The Pros)

• A Genuinely Unique & Fun Concept: You are the shark. You eat things. You grow. You evolve into a lightning-fast, bone-plated killing machine. It’s as simple and brilliant as it sounds.
  • Why this matters to you: It's a refreshing and empowering break from the standard fantasy or sci-fi RPGs. The pure, unadulterated fun of being a monster is a massive draw.
• Hilarious Narration & B-Movie Charm: The game is framed as a reality TV show, narrated with deadpan perfection by Chris Parnell (Archer, Rick and Morty). His commentary is consistently funny and elevates the entire experience.
  • Why this matters to you: The humor gives the game a personality that a silent shark protagonist couldn't. It turns what could be mindless chaos into a genuinely comedic and memorable adventure.
• The Addictive "Eat, Evolve, Repeat" Loop: There's a primal satisfaction in hunting prey, gaining nutrients, and returning to your grotto to upgrade your fins, teeth, and organs. You constantly feel a tangible sense of growing power.
  • Why this matters to you: This loop provides a steady stream of dopamine hits. Every play session results in noticeable progression, making it a perfect "pick up and play for an hour" game.

Common Complaints & Potential Deal-Breakers (The Cons)

• Repetitive Mission Design: After the initial thrill, you'll notice most missions boil down to "go here, eat 10 of X" or "destroy Y number of boats." The lack of variety is the game's single biggest weakness.
  • The real impact: The fun can start to feel like a grind, especially for completionists. What begins as a joyous rampage can devolve into checking boxes off a map.
• Occasionally Clunky Combat & Camera: Locking onto agile targets or fighting multiple bounty hunters can be frustrating. The camera can sometimes get stuck or whip around wildly during intense fights.
  • The real impact: This can lead to deaths that feel cheap rather than challenging, pulling you out of the power fantasy and causing moments of genuine frustration.
• Relatively Short for a Full-Priced Game: Most players can achieve 100% completion in about 15-20 hours. While there's a DLC, the base game experience is finite.
  • The real impact: If you're looking for a game to sink your teeth into for weeks on end, this isn't it. Its value proposition is much stronger when purchased on sale.

Feature Deep Dive: The "Eat, Evolve, Repeat" Loop - Genius or Grind?

The core of Maneater is its gameplay loop, and it's where most of the praise and criticism is focused. Initially, it's brilliant. Starting as a tiny pup and chomping on catfish is a humble beginning. When you finally evolve and can take on an alligator, it feels like a monumental achievement. The game is at its best during these moments of growth.

However, after about 5-7 hours, the pattern becomes starkly clear. Every new area introduces a slightly tougher set of the same fish and the same mission types. The "wow" factor of a new evolution (like electric teeth) is quickly tempered by the realization that you'll be using it to do the exact same things you were doing before. The system is, as many have noted, a mile wide but an inch deep. It's incredibly fun for a weekend, but it lacks the strategic depth to hold player interest for much longer.

Best Alternatives (The Competition)

1. Destroy All Humans!: If what you love about Maneater is the B-movie humor and the joy of causing chaos as a non-human entity, this is your best alternative. You trade fins for a flying saucer, but the spirit of gleeful, low-stakes destruction is identical.
2. Subnautica: If you're drawn to the underwater setting but crave depth, exploration, and genuine tension over action, Subnautica is a masterpiece. It swaps Maneater's power fantasy for a compelling survival-horror experience where you are the one being hunted.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)

1. How long does it take to beat Maneater?
For the main story, you can expect about 8-12 hours. For 100% completion of the base game, it's closer to 15-20 hours.

2. Is Maneater a difficult game?
Not particularly. It has some challenging boss fights and bounty hunter encounters, but the constant evolution and upgrades mean you can usually out-level any significant obstacle.

3. Is Maneater kid-friendly?
Absolutely not. The game is rated "M" for Mature for a reason. It features intense violence, blood and gore, and strong language. It's a game about a shark eating people, and it doesn't shy away from that.

4. Does Maneater have a multiplayer mode?
No, Maneater is a strictly single-player experience.

Final Thoughts & Recommendation

Maneater is the video game equivalent of a perfect summer blockbuster: explosive, hilarious, and not something you need to think too hard about. It knows exactly what it is—a "ShaRkPG"—and leans into its absurd premise with total confidence. The narration is a comedic masterclass, and the core gameplay loop is undeniably fun, at least for a while.

Its primary flaw is its own repetition. This isn't a game that will redefine the open-world genre. It's a digital palate cleanser; a perfect weekend game to play between sprawling, 100-hour epics.

My final verdict: If you can find Maneater on sale for under $30, it is an easy, enthusiastic recommendation. For that price, the 15-20 hours of unique, bloody fun are an absolute bargain.

Call to Action

Ready to take a bite out of crime (and everything else)? You can grab your copy of Maneater for the PlayStation 4 using the secure link below.

3. Audience Growth & Engagement

Become a WowShopList Insider

Love discovering products that are genuinely worth it? Subscribe to our exclusive WowShopList Weekly newsletter. Each week, we send one email featuring the most unique, innovative, and valuable products we find—our hidden gems. It's 100% free to join now, and you'll be locked in for life. We plan to make this a paid newsletter in the future, but our founding members will always get it for free.

We hope this in-depth review helps you make a confident choice! To continue your research, check out some of our other popular guides:

• The Best Open-World Games for PS4
• Our Picks for the Most Underrated RPGs of the Decade
• Buyer's Guide: The Best PS4 Games Under $30

Now we'd love to hear from you! Drop a comment below with your experience or any questions we didn't cover.